Rain

Gem172

scholar rank icondem.pferd.heisst.horst: check for EU key
novice rank iconKamilos31: Gentlemen, I want to buy the Polish Minecraft on PC, which one should I choose from the list because there is a lot of it here ???
scholar rank icondem.pferd.heisst.horst: Clap emote (inline chat version)
AdminJoshverd: Meowdy emote (inline chat version)
novice rank iconProffi216: ..
novice rank iconNachi: PParrot emote (inline chat version)
apprentice rank iconwagner_perac: yes
scholar rank iconhanfred: well just use the other survey providers
SystemGamehag: 7 users received Gem87 from the Rain.
apprentice rank iconwagner_perac: yes it was like that too, now not even these haha
scholar rank iconhanfred: all I get is 1 broken survey that does not work at all (says random reward survey)
SystemGamehag: Join our Discord for daily Gem giveaways!
novice rank iconMarietou Diagne: Wow
scholar rank iconhanfred: probably banned for no reason but maybe you get lucky
apprentice rank iconwagner_perac: There were quite a lot lately, now they have disappeared
scholar rank iconhanfred: worked for me for 2 days, that's it
scholar rank iconhanfred: you will never see surveys there again
novice rank iconImtiaz Bakare: ...........
apprentice rank iconwagner_perac: PepeHands emote (inline chat version) theorem hasn’t sent surveys for some days
novice rank iconLegendaryl: ahh yea the vpn fixed it thx
novice rank iconracim herazllah: hello
novice rank iconracim herazllah: vbn,
scholar rank icondem.pferd.heisst.horst: sometimes devices are not save like chinese mobile phones
apprentice rank iconwagner_perac: it may be due to region or your device that cannot use
novice rank iconnaoya1221kobayashi: why does it say the game is unavailable on your device
scholar rank icondem.pferd.heisst.horst: Modcheck emote (inline chat version)
SystemGamehag: Join our Discord for daily Gem giveaways!
novice rank iconNachi: blobDance emote (inline chat version)
apprentice rank iconwagner_perac: PepoDance emote (inline chat version)
novice rank iconJohnashdasya sjibadjua: i just payed out in rb
apprentice rank iconLeszek9028: Meowdy emote (inline chat version)
novice rank iconPoi: WHAT
scholar rank iconhanfred: Meowdy emote (inline chat version)
novice rank iconMarius Bartsch: ee
novice rank iconPoi: tell me yes or no
novice rank iconPoi: really
novice rank iconakademik: up
novice rank iconPoi: can u help me
novice rank iconPoi: hey
novice rank iconSelfishGene: yo
SystemGamehag: 8 users received Gem135 from the Rain.
novice rank iconPoi: what
novice rank iconJohnashdasya sjibadjua: Lol
novice rank iconPoi: heyyyyyyyyyy
novice rank iconPoi: hahah
SystemGamehag: Join our Discord for daily Gem giveaways!
novice rank iconAleksander Mikołajczyk: nah
novice rank iconPoi: aleksander
novice rank iconPoi: well u know how to eanr a lot
novice rank iconPoi: good
Sign in to start chatting

64

0/160

(25 ratings)
Gameplay Loops and What I learned from Horizon Zero Dawn

Gameplay Loops and What I learned from Horizon Zero Dawn

As a college educated video game developer, I make a point to critically analyze the games I play. Lately, I’ve been playing quite a few games that only grab my attention for maybe an hour long session, but after playing Horizon Zero Dawn, I’ve been able to pinpoint my problem exactly. This is a critical analysis on the state of repetition in current video games and a look into the nature of gameplay loops.

               I currently find myself in an unfortunate predicament. I am a recently graduated college educated game developer. On the surface this seems like an odd thing to call a predicament, but if you are in the industry then you know that most companies will not even consider hiring you unless you have some odd years of experience: experience you cannot obtain without being hired. From what I gather, this is a universal trend with 90s-born millennials (at least in the States). So, with this in mind, I’ve been spending a little under a year developing indie games; most of which will never see the light of day.

               So, what does this have to do with gameplay loops? Well, let’s just say in the few hours a day I can claw from my schedule to play an actual video game, I spend every second taking notes. I pause each game and break down every detail to what engine is used, to the art techniques in the texturing, to nature and writing of quests, to observations on AI and coding, and to, of course, the gameplay loops that are set up.

               To those who do not know what a gameplay loop is, it is exactly what it sounds like. This tends to be the case with most game-related terms: a side effect of being a new industry. Gameplay loops are simply the series of actions the player is expected to make while playing the game. In a hunting game for example, it would be to manage equipment and/or tags, track down the animal, and then shoot it. In a team match multiplayer game, it is to pick a map, get queued up, spawn, shoot enemy players or complete an objective, die, respawn, repeat the shooting of players onward until match ends. Simple, right?

               Well, it is too simple to be exact.

In linear games such a team multiplayer games or story focused ones, simple gameplay loops are often the best. You don’t want to do several different types of actions while an enemy team is firing at you, right? You want to know exactly what you need to do before the match starts, right? So, for the sake of the rest of the article, I will not be talking about those types of games. I’ll be talking mainstream triple-A games from here on out.

               So, in regard to triple-A games there is a notable trend going on. It has been going on for several years now, and can probably be attributed to the success of Skyrim. Triple-A games are almost entirely open world now. Even the most recent game of the Zelda franchise is open world. Ubisoft is practically a genre name now, as they have been pumping out reskins of the same game for years now. Look up any list of recently released triple-A games and you’ll find nearly all of them are open world.

               So, what is the problem here? Well, that is the big question, ain’t it? See, I’ve been finding myself not liking most triple-A games lately, and I’ve been struggling to find the answer why. I like open world games. I am still playing Skyrim, albeit, in a heavily modded form. Some have suggested that it is due to lack of content in these worlds. So how come games praised for being content heavy still bore me, like Breath of the Wild? The answer to this question has eluded me until I just last week.

               I had bought Horizon Zero Dawn: Complete Edition on sale at my local mall while out with some friends. I didn’t think too much on it. The game had been on my radar for quite some time, but had been rather low on my wishlist. I had gone so long before even considering it in wait of a reduced price. Well, there it was; complete edition, brand new, at a notably reduced price. I still hesitated. My mind went to little-played copy of Sea of Thieves on my desktop and the equally little played No Man’s Sky. It went to my friends copies of Far Cry games and Breath of the Wild, which both had been a chore to play despite my friends’ insistence otherwise. Still, I had money to burn and some time that night. I picked it up.

               Playing that game once I got home was some of the most fun I have had in ages.

               I enjoyed every cutscene and conversation. The lore intrigued me to no end. I played every sidequest and errand before continuing the main story. Every heard of machines I came across was wiped out as I passed by. I chased down animals with fervent glee. It made me worried about how much my stress was being released in these constant expressions of bloodlust.

               So what was the difference? Why did I spend 4-6 hours a session on Zero Dawn and only 30 minutes to an hour on all the other open world games? Cross-referencing my notes, I was able to pin it down to one thing: the gameplay loop.

               The gameplay loop of Horizon Zero Dawn was quite complicated compared to other open world games. In say, a Ubisoft game, you go to a place, talking to a guy, go to another place, kill a guy, go back and talk to the first guy, go to a tower, climb up it, reveal map, repeat. This has gotten a bit better with recent Far Cry games, but it is still pretty much the same loop throughout. Due to the repetition of this loop, by the time I got something else from the game, such as lore or story, I couldn’t care less. Zero Dawn’s loop, while similar on the surface, was much more complex. Go to a place, talk to a guy, “hey will you help us?” “sure”, protect the guys from machine creatures, a new machine you haven’t seen before shows up, scan it, find it’s weakness, you can’t stealth, now you can stealth, it is doing a thing now, I can shoot the weak spots now, everything it dead, talk to guy, you need to track down some other guy, follow their tracks to a new area, talk to that guy and learn why he did what he did, now he is dead, he was killed by a new machine you are barely strong enough to kill, etc, etc. And that wasn’t even main story; just a side mission that wasn’t even marked on the map.

               So, to make an easy quote: it is not the world or setting that makes an open world game good. It is the thought and care put into the gameplay loop. It is making each mission feel new and avoiding repetition.  It is making each encounter unique. Vast open worlds mean nothing if they are not filled with content, and content means nothing if the player has seen it before.